Marx's Grundrisse: Footnotes
53. The original text has 'personifications', evidently referring back to 'conditions'.
55. Having themselves become -- having themselves undergone the process of becoming.
56. On 22 February 1858, Marx wrote to Lassalle that he was planning three works: (1) a critique of the economic categories or the system of bourgeois economy critically presented, (2) a critique and history of political economy and socialism, and (3) a short historical sketch of the development of economic relations or categories (Marx-Engels Selected Correspondence, Moscow n.d., p. 125). Marx referred here to the third work, which he never produced in a completed form. Pages 459-514 of the present edition would no doubt have formed part of it.
57. Do ut facias: I give that you may do; facio ut des: I do that you may give; do ut des: I give that you may give. (Roman law.)
58. That is, with the free workers in manufactures (hand crafts).
59. Steuart, An Inquiry, Vol. I, p. 40.
60. Marx did not in fact mention this in the Chapter on Money but rather in the Chapter on Capital.
61. Adam Smith, Wealth of Nations, Vol. I, pp. 104-5.
62. State property.
63. The word Stamm here refers broadly to any extended kinship grouping; e.g. clan, tribe, gens, etc.
64. Geschlechter may also refer to the sexes, linguistic groups, generations, etc. It is not entirely certain which of these distinctions Marx had foremost in mind here.
65. This is one possible reconstruction of the sentence beginning 'The commune,' which has a number of grammatical loose ends in the original. Two other possible variants are presented in Pre-Capitalist Economic Formations, tr. J. Cohen, London, 1964, p. 73.
66. Craftsmen, workers
67. Georg Niebuhr, Römische Geschichte. Erster Theil. Zweyte, völlig umgearbeitete, Ausgabe, Berlin, 1827, p. 245.
68. The property of the quirites, ie. the Romans.
69. 'No Roman citizen was permitted to earn a livelihood as a tradesman or artisan Dionysius of Halicarnassus.' Roman Antiquities, Bk IV, Ch. 25).
70. The passages in pointed brackets, on pp.477-8, are taken from Niebuhrs Römische Geschichte. Erster Theil, and in this order: (1) p. 148; (2) pp. 435-6; (3) pp. 614-15 and footnotes 1224 and 1225; (4) pp. 317-18; (5) pp. 326-35.
1. Cicero, Letters to Atticus, Vol. V, 21, lines 10-13; Vol. VI, 1, lines 3-7; Vol. VI, 2, lines 7-10.
2. P.-J. Proudhon, Système des contradictions économiques, Vol. II, p. 265.
3. Latin plural of iugerum, a Roman measure of land.
4. Political animal; literally, city-dweller.